Posts

Showing posts with the label Whole-class instruction

Reading contextual cues during whole class learning

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com In a whole-class setting, knowing separate rules such as listening to the speaker or waiting for a turn is only part of what students need. They also need to recognize the boundaries that apply to their behavior at a particular moment: what the current situation allows and when an action begins to interfere with learning. To support this, we propose reading contextual cues as a classroom strategy. Students observe what is happening, identify relevant cues, connect them to work out the behavioral boundaries, and use that understanding to guide what they do. This approach draws on complementary ideas in the literature. Butler and Cartier (2004) describe task interpretation as fundamental to learning. It is an active process of searching for clues to task demands, making sense of expectations, drawing on relevant prior knowledge, and bringing these sources together to form criteria that guide performance. Boekaerts and Corno (2005) al...

Selective note taking during explanations

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com Taking notes while listening involves understanding what is being said, selecting information worth recording, and putting it into written form. Piolat, Olive, and Kellogg (2005) describe note taking as an activity combining comprehension, selection, and written production under time pressure. Learners have to manage these processes while new information continues to arrive. Jansen, Lakens, and IJsselsteijn (2017) describe the process in greater detail. Taking notes during a lecture involves comprehending the material, selecting key points, connecting them with what came before, paraphrasing or summarizing, and producing written notes. These processes recur throughout the lecture. A learner may also complete only part of the cycle: they might identify an important point, realize it is already in their notes, and return to listening without writing it again. In this article, we use selective note taking as a classroom term emphasizing...

Finding interest within the task

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com When a task does not immediately capture a learner's interest, they can learn to look within it for something that helps them stay engaged. This might be an aspect that arouses curiosity, offers a challenge, or gives the work meaning or an additional reason to continue. The aim is to make interest something the learner can influence while working. This approach draws on the literature on the regulation of motivation. Wolters (2003) describes interest enhancement as a set of strategies learners use to increase immediate enjoyment or situational interest during an activity, particularly one that is boring or repetitive. His examples show how learners may change the way they approach or carry out an activity to make it more engaging or challenging. Sansone and colleagues (1992) examine a similar process as a form of motivational self-regulation. They proposed that people committed to continuing an uninteresting activity may use interest...

Pausing before responding to make room for a decision

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com Pausing before responding creates a brief interval between the urge to reply and speaking. It gives the learner time to identify what they want to say and decide whether it needs to be said and whether the moment is appropriate. A response can then involve a degree of choice, instead of following immediately from a thought or feeling. This classroom approach draws on complementary ideas in emotion regulation research. O'Neal and colleagues (2024) examined a strategy they called “pause anger,” operationalized as waiting before acting when angry. In their study of upper elementary students, it was the strongest of five anger regulation predictors and the only one that predicted emotional engagement in school after the other strategies were taken into account. Zimmermann and Iwanski (2014), meanwhile, show that emotion regulation differs across emotions. Their findings revealed distinct developmental patterns in the regulation of sadnes...

Choosing when to speak during classroom discussion

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com Having an idea ready does not, by itself, determine when to speak. A student may have a correct answer, an important question, or a relevant comment while someone else still has the floor. The strategy addressed here is learning to manage the timing of expression: distinguishing between having something to say and recognizing a suitable moment to say it. This classroom approach draws on complementary ideas from research on emotion regulation in learning. Martínez-López and colleagues (2021) situate emotion regulation within self-regulated learning. Their review describes emotion regulation as an intentional process through which learners become aware of, monitor, evaluate, and adjust their emotional experiences, including decisions about when and how to use regulatory resources in pursuit of their goals. It also shows that the effects of emotions on learning depend on the emotion and the circumstances. Xu and Muis (2026) likewise emp...

Adaptive help seeking and learner independence

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com Adaptive help seeking means recognizing when continuing alone is no longer enough to overcome a difficulty and asking for the amount of help that will allow learning to continue independently. Help becomes one of the resources a learner uses to maintain their independence. This account draws directly on Newman (2002), who describes adaptive help seeking as seeking the help needed to learn independently, rather than simply to obtain the correct answer. Learners using this strategy monitor their performance, recognize a difficulty they cannot resolve alone, and take the initiative to request appropriate help from someone more knowledgeable. Newman therefore places adaptive help seeking among the strategies of self-regulated learning. In this article, we treat other people as learning resources whom students can consult without handing over responsibility for the task. Independence includes knowing when help is needed, what to ask for, ...

When students cross boundaries without recognizing them

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com The teacher or a student is speaking to the class when background noises, imitations, scattered comments, or small movements and sounds begin to interfere. These actions affect more than the student making them. They compete with the speaker and draw others' attention away, breaking the shared listening on which the moment depends. Telling the student to be quiet or stop may end the disruption for the moment. But the teacher has identified the boundary for them. The student still needs to learn how to recognize the behavioral boundaries indicated by the situation itself. Reading contextual cues can help. Who is speaking now? Is the explanation or presentation still in progress? Has discussion opened? Has the speaking turn passed to someone else? By noticing and connecting these cues, students become better able to recognize what the situation currently allows and what goes beyond its limits. Make the pattern of participation visible The ...

Helping students stay focused through note taking

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com A few minutes into an explanation, a student starts talking to a classmate, keeps looking around, writes something unrelated, or gets absorbed in what is on their phone. Another may seem to have stopped following altogether. Any one of these behaviors does not necessarily mean that a student is no longer listening or understanding. The difficulty arises when attention repeatedly moves away from the explanation, leaving gaps that make the line of reasoning harder to follow. “Focus” or “Stay with me” may bring the student's attention back briefly. But the teacher has redirected it. Students still need a way to keep their own attention connected to an explanation when they begin to drift away. Note taking can help by giving them something to look for as they listen: information worth keeping. They identify something important, capture it in a few words, and return to listening. They do not need to write everything the teacher says or become...

When jokes shift students’ attention away from learning

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com You are explaining an idea when a student makes an unrelated joke. A few classmates laugh, the student adds another comment, and the explanation begins to lose its thread. Humor itself is not the difficulty. The problem is that comments unrelated to the task interrupt the lesson and draw the student's attention, along with that of classmates, away from what they are learning. Asking the student to stop joking and return to the lesson may bring them back for the moment. But the teacher has redirected their attention. The student still needs to learn how to do this themselves when their interest in the task begins to fade. They can learn to look within the task for something that gives them a reason to stay with it: a question that arouses curiosity, a challenge they want to understand, or a use they would like to discover. They do not always need a compelling reason to love the task. They need a way back into it, rather than waiting for so...

When students interrupt to disagree

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com The teacher is explaining an idea, or a student is answering in front of the class, when someone interrupts: “No, that's wrong.” They may begin correcting the speaker before the explanation is finished, start discussing the point on the spot, or respond immediately because something seems unclear or unfair. The student may be listening, comparing ideas, and making judgments. Their objection may be valid. The difficulty is that it comes before the speaker has finished, breaking the explanation and sometimes turning it into a side discussion in front of the class. Saying “Wait until the speaker has finished” may stop the interruption briefly, but it leaves the teacher in charge of deciding when the student can speak. The student still needs to learn how to make that decision independently. A brief pause between “I disagree” or “I'm upset” and “I'm going to speak now” can help. During that pause, the student first clarifies their thought,...

Helping students participate without interrupting

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com A student is following an explanation when an answer or idea comes to mind, and they say it immediately. They might finish the teacher's sentence, jump ahead to the conclusion, add an example or comment before the speaker has finished, or ask a question about something that has not yet been explained. These behaviors differ, but they share one feature: the student speaks before it is their turn. The student wants to participate. The difficulty is that speaking before the other person has finished or before being given the floor breaks the flow of the discussion. Others may lose the chance to complete their thought or have time to think. Participation itself can then become disruptive. Repeatedly saying “Wait your turn” may stop the interruption, but the teacher still decides when the student should speak and when they should wait. If that decision always rests with the teacher, the student has little opportunity to learn how to manage the m...

When students keep asking for help during explanations

Image
Manal Raoui  |  manalraoui.com You are explaining an idea to the class when you hear a student ask: “I don't understand this step.” “How did you get that result?” “Could you explain that idea again?” A few moments later, another question follows. Then another. Asking questions is part of learning. The difficulty arises when a student turns to the teacher at the first sign of uncertainty, before trying to use what they already know or consulting another resource. The teacher becomes the first step whenever something is unclear. Answering immediately every time may resolve the difficulty at hand while keeping this pattern in place. We continue to decide what the student should do when they do not know, leaving them little opportunity to learn how to assess their need for help, consider what they could try first, and decide when they need another resource. Students need a brief space between “I don't know” and calling for the teacher. This is an opportunity to pause,...